Yes we are, as long as you can back up your position with an argument. There are many ambiguous areas in Tolkien that are open to debate - while we normally try to highlight these, there are inevitably points where some visitors disagree with statements on the site. We're always ready to reconsider the content of entries if you can argue persuasively in favour of your position.

Please bear in mind, though, that at this early stage most of the entries are incomplete. Often, we're intending to discuss a debatable issue but we haven't yet got around to adding that discussion to the entry. In the more debatable areas of Tolkien's work, we'll try to cover all sides of the argument at the time when the entry is updated.